Best Mid-Range Restaurants in City Island
The best meals in City Island don't always come with the biggest price tags. These mid-range restaurants hit the sweet spot — impressive food, fair prices, and no sticker shock.
10 curated spots
Get personalized picks based on your vibe
Sign Up Free
Vistamar Restaurant & Lounge
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Waterside Latin American restaurant-lounge with live music, standout cocktails, and a lively patio.
Archie's Tap & Table
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Modern-rustic City Island tavern with a patio, great cocktails, and comfort-food plates.
City Island Lobster House
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
City Island seafood institution with waterfront patio, lobster platters, and a lively bar.
Sammy's Fish Box
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
City Island seafood institution with huge platters, stained-glass booths, and a bustling bar.
The Original Crab Shanty
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
City Island seafood institution with nautical vibes, big platters, and a bustling bar.
Sea Shore Restaurant
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Historic City Island seafood with marina views, a patio, and a cozy fireplace.
Tony's Pier
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Bustling City Island pier-style seafood spot with outdoor tables, bar, and late-night bites.
Seafood City
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Spacious City Island seafood counter with arcade games, strong cocktails, and a big patio.
Sammy's Smokehouse
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Bustling City Island spot for seafood, BBQ comfort plates, and fruity cocktails.
Seafood Kingz 2 Inc
Great value — quality restaurant at $ pricing
Black-owned City Island seafood and soul-food spot with bar, fast service, big platters.
Explore More
Find your perfect spot
Get AI-powered recommendations tailored to your vibe, budget, and occasion.
Get Started — It's Free